More small businesses are adding an AI website chatbot to their site this winter. It answers at midnight and never tires of “are you open on Boxing Day?”. It can also make promises you never agreed to. There’s already a well known case that shows what happens next.
The airline, the chatbot and the refund rule
In November 2022, after their grandmother died, Jake Moffatt went on Air Canada’s website to book flights. They asked the chatbot about bereavement fares. The chatbot said they could book now and apply for the reduced fare within 90 days of the ticket being issued. They did exactly that. Air Canada then said its policy didn’t allow bereavement claims after travel, and refused.
The chatbot had even linked to the airline’s own bereavement page, which said the opposite. Air Canada argued Mr Moffatt should have found the correct information there.
At the Civil Resolution Tribunal in British Columbia, Air Canada also argued, in effect, that it couldn’t be held responsible for what its chatbot said. The tribunal called this “a remarkable submission”. It said it should be obvious to Air Canada that it is responsible for all the information on its website, and that it makes no difference whether that information comes from a static page or a chatbot.
In February 2024 the tribunal ordered Air Canada to pay C$812.02 in damages, interest and fees.
It’s Canadian, so why should you care?
This was a small claims decision in Canada. It isn’t UK law, and I’m a web designer, not a lawyer, so please don’t read this as legal advice. But the principle is the one any customer would expect: if your website tells me something, that’s you telling me. If your chat box gives a guest the wrong refund rule, deposit terms or allergen answer, “the bot said it, not us” won’t feel like a good answer to them, whatever a court might decide.
Small businesses are more exposed, not less
A big airline can absorb a mistake of about C$800. A small restaurant whose chatbot promises a free birthday dessert to everyone who asks, or a salon whose bot tells a customer cancellations are free up to an hour before, will feel it. Often you find out when the customer turns up with a screenshot. A website chatbot speaks for your business, so a wrong answer about refunds, deposits or allergens is your answer.
Six rules for a website chatbot that won’t make promises for you
- Give it your real policies, in writing. Refunds, deposits, cancellations, hours, delivery areas. If it hasn’t been given the answer, it shouldn’t guess.
- Make some topics “hand over” topics. Prices and discounts, refunds, complaints, and anything about allergies or health should go to a person, or link to the exact page, every time.
- Link to the source, and make sure the answer matches it. A good answer ends with “Here’s our cancellation policy” and a link. In the Air Canada case there was a link, but the bot’s own words said something different, and that didn’t save the airline.
- Say it’s a bot. A small “Automated assistant” label sets expectations and stops people thinking they’ve had a promise from the owner.
- Keep the transcripts. If a customer says “your chat told me”, you want to read what it actually said.
- Update it when you change things. New Christmas hours or a new deposit rule? Change the bot on the same day you change the website.
Related: Is ChatGPT recommending your business? A 20 minute check
The 10 awkward questions test
Once a month, ask your own chatbot ten questions a difficult customer might ask. For example (made up questions, change them to suit your business):
- Can I get a refund if I cancel tomorrow?
- Is the deposit refundable?
- Do you do a discount for students?
- Is the chicken gluten free?
- Can I bring my dog?
- Are you open on Boxing Day?
- What’s your cheapest option?
- Can I pay later?
- Will you match a competitor’s price?
- My voucher has expired. Can I still use it?
If any answer is wrong, vague or more generous than your real policy, fix your website chatbot before a customer finds it. If it can’t pass, a clear FAQ page and a fast “message us” button might do the job better.
Want me to test yours?
If you’ve got a chatbot on your site, or you’re thinking about adding one, send me the link (or your ten most common customer questions). I’ll run the awkward questions test and send you what I’d change, free. Email contact@shaandesigns.com or message me on X @Shaan_Designs with PROMISE.
Waqar, Shaan Designs
Website chatbot: quick answers
What happened in the Air Canada chatbot case?
Air Canada’s website chatbot told Jake Moffatt they could apply for a bereavement fare within 90 days of the ticket being issued. Air Canada later refused because its policy didn’t allow claims after travel. In February 2024 the Civil Resolution Tribunal in British Columbia ordered the airline to pay C$812.02 in damages, interest and fees.
Is the Air Canada chatbot case UK law?
No. It was a small claims decision in Canada. It isn’t UK law, and this isn’t legal advice.
How can I check my website chatbot is safe?
Run the 10 awkward questions test against your real policies. If it fails, a clear FAQ page and a fast “message us” button may work better.
Source: Moffatt v. Air Canada, 2024 BCCRT 149, Civil Resolution Tribunal of British Columbia, decision issued 14 February 2024: Moffatt v. Air Canada decision. This article is general information about a Canadian decision, not UK law and not legal advice.