Before you drop a payment method over fees, check two numbers: how many of your orders use it, and what it really costs per £100 taken.
Earlier this month, a Leeds designer and tailor posted on X that he’d switched PayPal off on his website. His reasons: far fewer of his customers use it than when he started in 2012, and a recent rate of 4.25% wasn’t viable for him.
That’s his business and his numbers, and he may well be right. But it’s a question a lot of small shops are asking right now, especially with Christmas orders about to land. Should we drop PayPal? Klarna? Bank transfer? Cards only?
The honest answer: it depends on two numbers, and most owners have never looked at either.
Number one: how many of your orders use it
Start with the last 12 months, so Christmas and the quiet months are both in there. Your payment provider’s dashboard (Stripe, PayPal, Square and so on) will show you how much went through it. In WooCommerce, every order shows the payment method used, and an order export plugin will give you a spreadsheet you can sort.
What you want is simple: out of every 100 orders, how many came through each method? If a button handles 3 orders a year, it’s clutter. If it handles 30 out of every 100, switching it off is a big decision.
Do this for every payment method you offer, not just the one you’re thinking of cutting.
Number two: what a payment method really costs per £100 taken
Don’t go by the headline rate on a pricing page. Look at your actual statements. Add up the fees you paid on one method over a few months, divide by what you took through it, and multiply by 100. That’s your real cost per £100.
Do the same for your card payments. Now you’re comparing like with like. Sometimes the gap is big. Sometimes it’s a few pence and not worth the fuss. Include the extras too: currency conversion, refunds and disputes can all change the picture.
The number nobody checks: the sales you might lose
Here’s the catch. Some people pay with a particular method because it’s the only one they’re happy using online. They don’t want to type card details into a site they’ve never used before, or they’re paying from a balance, or they simply trust it. Remove it and a few of them will pay another way. A few will close the tab.
So the real sum isn’t “fees saved”. It’s fees saved minus the profit on the orders you lose. You can’t get that second number from a spreadsheet, which is why the next step matters.
If you’d rather make each order worth more than cut options, see six ways your website can raise average order value.
Test it, don’t guess
If you’re unsure, run a test in a quiet month rather than in December. Hide the method for four to six weeks and watch three things: how many orders you get, how many baskets are abandoned at checkout, and whether anyone emails asking where it went. Compare with the same weeks before. If nothing changes, you have your answer. If abandoned checkouts jump, switch it back on and you’ve lost very little.
In WooCommerce, turning a payment method off or on is a setting, not a rebuild, so a test like this is cheap.
If you do remove it, tell people
Nobody likes discovering at the last step that their usual way to pay has gone. Put a line on your checkout and in your FAQs, for example: “We now take card, Apple Pay and Google Pay.” (Only list what you actually offer.) If you have regulars, mention it in your next email. A small note saves a lot of “your checkout’s broken” messages.
The short version
Count how many orders use it. Work out what it really costs per £100. Test removing it in a quiet month. Then decide with numbers, not with a hunch or a headline. A payment method that costs a bit more but brings in a steady share of orders is often worth keeping.
Payment method fees: quick answers
Should I stop taking PayPal on my website?
Not on the headline fee alone. Check what share of orders over the last 12 months use it and what it really costs per £100, then test hiding it for four to six weeks in a quiet month.
How do I work out what a payment method really costs?
Add up all fees for that method on your statements, including currency conversion, refunds and disputes, divide by what it took, and multiply by 100. Compare that with cards.
Is it hard to turn a payment method off in WooCommerce?
No. It’s a setting, not a rebuild, so you can switch it back on if abandoned checkouts jump.
If you’d like a second pair of eyes on your checkout and payment options, send me your shop link. I’ll tell you honestly what I’d keep, what I’d test and what I’d tidy up. Email contact@shaandesigns.com, call or WhatsApp on +44 7787 090 526, or start a project.
Waqar, Shaan Designs
The 4.25% figure is one shop owner’s own experience, not a standard rate. Fees vary by provider, plan and transaction type, so always check your own statements.