On 8 November, 7NEWS in Australia ran a short report about Adorn Cosmetics, a Melbourne skincare brand. Its founder, Briony Kennedy, says that after the company moved its online shop to Adobe Commerce, sales dropped by “about 30 odd percent” as soon as the new site launched. She says the Facebook and Instagram ads she was paying for, about a million dollars a year by her account, “were not linking back to the website”. The report says she laid off staff, sold her family home, moved again to Shopify, and that she now faces bankruptcy.
That is one side of the story. Adobe told 7NEWS it would not comment for legal reasons, a mediation attempt failed, and Kennedy says she’s taking steps towards court. The report doesn’t say exactly what broke, how long it lasted or who was responsible for fixing it. So I’m not going to tell you who’s to blame. I don’t know.
What I do know is that the detail in the middle of her story is the most common way a website move goes wrong, at any size.
Your website has more doors than you think
When you change platform, or even just tidy up your page addresses, pages can get new addresses. The old address doesn’t follow unless someone tells it to. And plenty of things still point at the old one:
- the ads you’re paying for
- your Google Business Profile
- your Instagram and TikTok bio links
- QR codes printed on menus, table cards, flyers and the side of the van
- links in old emails, newsletters and booking confirmations
- other websites that mention you, like local guides and directories
Every one of those is a door. After a move, some of them can open onto an error page. Your customers don’t see a platform change. They see a dead end, and most of them leave.
The fix is boring, and it works
The tool for this is a redirect, usually a “301”, which tells browsers and Google “this page has moved permanently, it’s over here now”. Google’s own site move guide says to keep redirects “for as long as possible, generally at least 1 year”, warns against sending lots of old pages to the home page, and lists ad campaigns among the links to update.
Here’s the checklist I’d want ticked before any move goes live:
- List every old address that matters. Your analytics will show which pages actually get visits. Start there.
- Map each old address to its new home. Not everything to the home page. A product link should land on that product.
- List every link you control outside the website. Ads, profiles, bios, QR codes, email templates. Write them down.
- Click every one on launch day. Then again a week later. On a phone, not just a laptop.
- Watch the till, not just the traffic. If sales dip the week you launch, check the links before you blame the weather.
- Keep a way back. Know how you’d put the old site back up for a day if you had to.
Don’t move unless you need to
The line in the report that stuck with me was the advice at the end: “Don’t change what’s not broken.” Kennedy says she was given a written projection of 34% to 94% revenue growth when she was pitched. I can’t check that, and it hasn’t been tested in court. But I’ve heard the smaller version of the pitch many times: a shiny new platform will fix everything.
Sometimes a move is right. Your current site might be insecure, unable to take payments the way you need, or costing more than it earns. But ask whoever proposes it three questions first:
- What exactly will be better, and how will we measure it?
- What could break?
- Who is responsible for checking every link on launch day?
If nobody can answer the third one, don’t sign yet.
The bit I’d remember
Nobody remembers a website launch for the design. They remember it if the phone stops ringing.
Follow the links.
If you’re planning a move and want a second pair of eyes on the link list, that’s the kind of job I do. Start a project or email contact@shaandesigns.com.
Sources: 7NEWS Australia, “Cosmetics empire crumbles after Adobe website disaster”, 8 Nov 2026 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TnicUxFL64E); PPC Land, 9 Nov 2026 (https://ppc.land/adorn-cosmetics-faces-closure-blaming-30-sales-drop-on-adobe-site/); Briony Kennedy on LinkedIn; Google Search Central, “Site moves and migrations” (https://developers.google.com/search/docs/crawling-indexing/site-move-with-url-changes).